Shop / Prompts & Skills / Book Club Discussion Questions From Your Reading Passage — AI Skill With Evidence Lines, No Spoilers

When the passage contradicts itself — hold the questions

Discussion questions built from the passage in front of your group — each one paired with the exact line it comes from. No imported plot points, no spoilers. That works while the passage agrees with itself. Sometimes it does not: one line says the envelope was gone, another implies it was still there; the summary the facilitator pasted disagrees with the page the group actually read. That is when the question set does not get written at all — the clarification questions come out instead.

The supported case: questions that stay inside the passage

This is a real output from the question lab skill — two questions, each carrying its evidence line:

STATUS: READY
QUESTIONS:
- What might Mira's choice to leave the invitation suggest, without assuming her motive?
  EVIDENCE: "Mira folded the invitation and left it on the windowsill."
- How does the missing envelope change what readers can confidently say happened?
  EVIDENCE: "the envelope was gone."
SOURCE CHECK:
- Both evidence phrases appear in SUPPLIED_EXCERPT_OR_SUMMARY.

Sample data above is fictional, shown so you can judge the output before buying.

Notice what the first question does not do: it asks what Mira's choice might suggest 'without assuming her motive'. The passage shows the act — Mira folded the invitation and left it on the windowsill — not the reason. The second question turns on the missing envelope: what readers can confidently say changes when a fact the passage asserted is gone. Both questions stay inside the lines the group can point at. The source check confirms both evidence phrases appear in the supplied excerpt before the set is marked ready.

What the contradiction case looks like

When the material is missing or contradictory, the skill returns clarification questions under HOLD instead of inventing discussion material. The questions it asks are the ones only the facilitator can answer:

A question set built on a contradiction is not a discussion — it is a spoiler wearing a question mark, or an argument about a scene half the group never read. The HOLD costs the facilitator a day of checking; a set that invents its own evidence costs the group its trust in the questions. The evidence-line method itself is covered in our earlier guide, Book Club Discussion Questions From the Passage in Front of You.

The tool for this job

Book Club Discussion Questions From Your Reading Passage — AI Skill With Evidence Lines, No Spoilers — Discussion questions built from the passage in front of your group — each one paired with the exact line it comes from. No imported plot points, no spoilers.

$7.99 Buy on Payhip See the full product page →

Instant download after checkout. Sold and delivered by Payhip. More tools like this live on the Prompts & Skills shelf.

Questions

Does it fill in missing details?

No — its instructions prohibit inventing details and require flags for uncertainty; AI output can still be wrong, so you must review it.

Do I need a paid add-on, API, or connected account?

No — you need access to a compatible AI chat; access limits and any chat-service charges depend on that provider.

Is the draft ready to send or publish without review?

No — the status and source checks are intended to support human verification first.